30 Fun Ways to Decide Fantasy Football Draft Order
Updated
How to decide your fantasy football draft order: 30 fun, fair ideas for every kind of league, from quick random draws and duck races to trivia nights, remote-league reveals and earned-order systems like KDL. Many come with a one-tap tool to try them.
Setting the draft order is the first big moment of every fantasy season. A good method is fair, quick to explain, and fun enough that people talk about it in the group chat. Here are 30 ways to do it. Where the draft order generator can run an idea for you, there's a Try it button that opens it in that mode.
Quick picks (5 minutes)
When you just need an order and want a little fun, these take five minutes or less.
- Plain shuffle. Paste the names and get the order at once. Best when nobody cares about a show, only that it was fair. Post the replay link so everyone can check it. Try it
- Spin the wheel. A wheel spin for every pick, and each name drops off once it's picked. Pick 1 goes to the first name the wheel lands on. Good on a video call: share your screen. Try it
- Lottery balls. Balls come out one at a time from the last pick to the first, like a pro draft lottery. Works with equal balls or with extra balls for the worst teams. Try it
- Envelope reveal. One sealed envelope per pick, opened in reverse order. Great for a slow, dramatic reveal at a draft party. Try it
- Dice roll-off. Everyone rolls two dice; highest total picks first, and ties roll again. Easy in person, and fun to film.
- Names in a hat. Write each name on paper, fold it and pull them out one by one. Old school and still fair, if someone films it for the remote managers.
- Deck of cards. Each manager draws a card; highest card picks first (aces high, suits break ties). Shuffle in front of everyone.
Race reveals
Races turn the draw into a show. The order is decided before the race starts, so the race is pure entertainment.
- Duck race. Rubber ducks float down a river, one per manager. First duck across the line takes pick 1. The replay link lets everyone rewatch the exact same race. Try it
- Horse race. A horse race down the track, with names on every lane. Turn on Live mode and put it on the big screen. Try it
- 100-yard race. Footballs race the length of a field to the end zone. Perfect for a football league. Try it
- Marble race. Build a marble run (or use a store-bought track), give each manager a marble, and film it. Practice the track first so marbles don't get stuck.
- Pick a horse in a real race. Each manager is given a horse in any televised race by a random draw; the finishing order sets the draft order. Draw the horses with the plain shuffle so nobody picks the favorite. Try it
Skill and luck games
Some leagues want the order to be earned on the day. Mix a little skill with luck so everyone has a chance.
- Pick the score. Everyone guesses the final score of a preseason or college game. Closest to the real total picks first. Use the total points to break ties.
- Football trivia night. Run a round of 20 questions on the big screen with our football trivia quiz in team mode. Highest score picks first.
- Cornhole tournament. A quick bracket in the backyard. Winner picks first, then the losers of each round in order.
- Closest to the pin. One shot each on a golf hole, a mini-golf hole or a driving range target. Closest ball picks first.
- Video game tournament. Play a short football video game bracket. Keep games to one quarter so the night doesn't run long.
- Free-throw contest. Ten shots each; most makes picks first, and ties shoot again.
- Paper football flick. The classic folded-paper football, flicked through finger goalposts across a table. Most field goals in five tries picks first.
- Rock-paper-scissors bracket. A silly single-elimination bracket. Seed it with the plain shuffle, then play best of three.
Remote leagues
Half the league lives somewhere else? These work over a video call or a group chat.
- Live-streamed race. Share your screen on a video call and run the duck or horse race in Live mode. Everyone sees it at the same moment. Try it
- Shared link reveal. Run the draw, then post the replay link in the group chat. Anyone can open it and watch the same race, so it's fair even if nobody was online at the time. Try it
- Group chat lottery. Post the weighted odds table in the chat, get a thumbs-up from everyone, then run the lottery and post the link. Try it
- Guess the number. The commissioner writes down a secret number from 1 to 1,000 and shares it after everyone guesses. Closest picks first.
- Daily game challenge. Everyone plays the same daily game, like Guess the NFL Player, on the same day. Fewest guesses picks first; ties go to the faster time.
Earned order (KDL)
Many keeper and dynasty leagues reward last season, or let managers choose their slot.
- Last year's standings, reversed. The worst team picks first and the champion picks last. Simple and fair for leagues that want parity.
- KDL: Kentucky Derby Lottery. A random race sets the order in which managers choose their draft slot. Some prefer pick 1, others like the turn at the end of a snake. Run the race, then let the winner choose first. Try it
- Consolation bracket. Non-playoff teams play a "toilet bowl" bracket; the winner earns pick 1 (or first choice of slot). It keeps bad teams trying until the end of the season.
- Weighted lottery for non-playoff teams. Lock playoff teams into the last slots in reverse finishing order, and run a weighted lottery for the rest, with more balls for the worst records. Try it
- Auction for draft slots. Give everyone the same play-money budget and auction off the slots. Managers who love pick 1 can pay for it; the leftover budget becomes extra waiver money.
Rules that keep it fair
Whatever method you pick, a few simple rules stop arguments before they start:
- Announce the method early. Post it in the league chat at least a week before the draw, and get everyone's okay.
- Decide before anyone knows the result. Odds, keeper slots and tie-breakers must be set before the draw, never after.
- Record the reveal. Film the hat draw, stream the race or share the replay link. A random draw that nobody saw isn't proof.
- One draw only. No "best of three" after the fact. If the method fails (a marble gets stuck), agree in advance what happens.
- Make skill games accessible. If a contest favors one person (the golfer in a golf contest), mix in luck, or let remote managers take part in the same way.
- Write it in the league rules so next year's draw follows the same method.
Once you have an order, check what it means for the whole draft with the snake, linear and third-round-reversal boards in the draft order generator. Then build the season with the schedule maker, and settle on a league name.
Questions and answers
What is the fairest way to pick draft order?
A random draw everyone can see, such as a recorded race or a shared result link.
What is KDL?
Kentucky Derby Lottery: managers pick their draft slot in an order set by a random race.
How do remote leagues decide draft order?
Use a shared link reveal or stream a race on a video call.
Should the worst team get the first pick?
Some leagues use a weighted lottery for that; it's a league choice.